Surprisingly, football was not his initial passion; as a young child, Coffey was initially drawn to baseball. However, witnessing the success of those around him in football shifted his perspective and ultimately changed his heart.
“Football was clearly the goal and vehicle,” Coffey said. “There’s something that’s fundamentally wild about you and your teammates fired up and going crazy. There’s the pageantry of a pep rally, there’s a fight song. There’s a whole experience, it just made it fun.”
While he started his football journey as a wide receiver, it was during his time at Southwest Texas State University (now Texas State University) that a coach recommended Coffey make the switch from wide receiver to defensive back. Coffey recalls his coach telling him “You got good hands; you can play receiver..., [but] if you’re a really good defensive back, you’ll always have a job.”